FIXTURESNo upcoming fixtures — check back soon.
FORUM / RUGBY /  Thoughts on ABs V Ireland

Thoughts on ABs V Ireland

Started by Plum2 REPLIES56 VIEWS· 18 Jul 2026, 10:28
SHAREXFACEBOOKWHATSAPPTELEGRAMREDDITLINKEDIN
Plum
PlumCaptain21,324 posts
18 Jul 2026, 10:28
#1
18 Jul 2026, 10:28#1

The most dominant the ABs looked was when they cleared the ruck quickly and used one-off runners to drive Ireland back.

The Irish made so many crazy mistakes and I can't remember the last time I watched them have such a high error count at such critical moments in the game.

In the post I made that previewed this game, I mentioned how the ABs might remind Ireland of their insecurities. And it felt like that to me. JGP, often going an entire game with no errors, was all over the place at times and stifled Ireland's momentum on a few occasions. Pretender also chucked a few passes into touch. McCloskey's pass behind his own players in Ireland's 22 was probably the moment that sealed the game because Ireland had just gotten a score back and were getting into it. Suddenly that score was nullified and an adrenaline dump ensued.

Neither pack looked particularly powerful to me. The ABs look very snappy at the ruck but not too powerful.

Ireland's pack looked shaky at best.

Scrums were almost a non-entity again in this game with only 2 or 3 scrums actually completed. As Bok fans we need to be very worried about this because we won the last World Cup on the back of scrums and the international matches this year have shown how the scrum is becoming less and less important. It seems like I'm the only one noticing this.

Think about it...3 completed scrums a game is 1.5 scrums a half. Against England, I believe the completed scrum count was also very low at maybe 3 or 4. It's worrying.

Love was excellent again for the ABs. I think the jersey is his now or, at least, it should be. He looks like he has a good eye for positional play and makes the right decisions. Also a bit of a fighter.

Pretender remains sketchy at test level. I'm not a fan. He had one particularly good spell but was pretty average the rest of the time. And even if he had a good game I'd probably still say he sucked because I just can't find a smidgen of love for him.

Ardie was Ardie. Easily the most likeable AB of them all and always makes positive contributions - Roos, are you watching!?!? You don't need to be a hulk...just use your brain and pick your battles.

Side note - There are some truly stark similarities between Ardie and Hanekom. Anyone else notice this?

Jordan was also very good again. Some excellent scramble defence and a crucial turnover to shut Ireland out of the game at a crucial moment.

Probably my favourite player, Caleb, was proper when he came on. I don't know how a guy with that much power and explosiveness doesn't start for the ABs. No idea what form he is in at franchise level but whenever I've watched him he has always looked like the kind of backline player that should be a no-brainier in any international side.

Dmac was also very good. I've always thought he was massively overrated but he's had a few excellent games on the bounce now. Good to see and I'm sure his from makes Rooi happy since he's always sing Dmac's praises.

Where do the Boks sit in relation to the ABs?

I think that the Boks looked rattled against Scotland and this AB side is far better than Scotland. They're more efficient in what they do and seem to do a lot of it slightly more quickly than what one expects. I wouldn't say its alarm bells for the Boks but if we can't slow their ruck down enough things could get out of hand quickly.

All in all the ABs appear on the up and Ireland seem to be retreating to where they belong, which is to look like the 5th ranked test side.

Just some thoughts.

Pakie
PakieCaptain17,609 posts
18 Jul 2026, 12:04
#2
18 Jul 2026, 12:04#2

I think the Irish have two packs: the one with Doris and the one without him. As honest a grafter as Conan is, Doris is a presence.

All Blacks were good. They committed very few players to the Irish breakdowns leaving the Irish with little space to attack. As I said during the game, Ireland needed to punch around the breakdown and ruck fringes more to get the ABs narrower. ABs did that very well, used the entire width of the field to stretch the Irish defense, found space on the edges and the opportunities came.

I heard you about the scrums. Getting harder to use as a weapon. The Boks may have only themselves to blame for that after overdoing it to the point of parody against Ireland last year. There's no way someone wasn't going to sit up and take notice.

I thought the AB pack was pretty good, the heavies that came from the bench challenged the Irish defense as well. Jordie was excellent, didn't give McC an inch on defense and my impression was that he was an important cog in the distribution too. Caleb is a weapon for sure, but Moorby is handy as well. Dmac was good, Roigard too. Just a few names that pop up, there were many others.

Prenny was his usual erratic self. I knew he was going to be back in the Irish side again after the few good outings he had towards the end of the URC, but yeah, you know what you get. He's at his best with the little short passes and close distribution, but put a little heat on him and get into the line outside him and his decision making and execution goes to shit. Don't know who else you play for Ireland though, they don't really have a standout 10 right now.

I'm just happy that the ABs seem to be firing some proper shots again.

BE
Beeno1Captain40,080 posts
18 Jul 2026, 13:40
#3
18 Jul 2026, 13:40#3

"I'm just happy that the ABs seem to be firing some proper shots again" says ou Pakster
What an understatement!
Plumpster the AB pack looked pretty solid to me. Wonder what their collective weight was.

— END OF THREAD —

More from Rugby

More news