FIXTURESNo upcoming fixtures — check back soon.
FORUM / RUGBY /  Yes, but what about Kolisi.... highest win rate

Yes, but what about Kolisi.... highest win rate

Started by kingcorn2 REPLIES17 VIEWS· 08 Sept 2026, 10:02
SHAREXFACEBOOKWHATSAPPTELEGRAMREDDITLINKEDIN
KI
kingcornPro3,838 posts
08 Sept 2026, 10:02
#1
08 Sept 2026, 10:02#1

You okes know my gripes with Kolisi and it has bee like this for years. Not that he is a flashy player and can attack, does makes his tackles when the player does see him, but he is an open side flank and has never performed his job as an opensider. His body position in the ruck has always been poor, he may charge in and nudge the player or he may ride a tackle, but was blatantly obvious is how he hides around the ruck, never the first to tackle and if he does defenders go over him, he then loiters around and then shift out, avoiding contact as often as he can. Then you see Malcom Marx, Hannekom and so many other players just sticking their head in. Here is a sequence of play from Kolisi that led to the first try.

image

Stands on the edge

image

Reinachs goes past him and he slips in the pocket un noticed

image

Then Nortje comes in from one side, yet Kolisi then goes in to take the hit. He has two players that already showed down the number 2 before he made contact.

image

He takes the hit, but instead of dominating a slowing player, he gets driven 4 meters back, not a real tackle and just rides the tackle to avoid any force.

image

Never puts his head over the ball to slow it down or actually tackle the player.

image

Simple pop pass and Kolisi are left clutching at straws.

He does this every game and we concede so much when he is at the break down. This was in the first 5 min.

To me he has always been a construct and never a real player.

As Dave use to say, a player needs a hard edge, Kolisi never had one and tricked people in believing he is a great player.

Stolen Valour thanks to the ANC forcing Rassie and so many coaches before him to make him look good.

Saw what happened to that professor from Cambridge, here is another case of somebody that has all the accolade put against him when it is clear as day that he doesn't deserve it.

BE
Beeno1Captain40,360 posts
08 Sept 2026, 10:40
#2
08 Sept 2026, 10:40#2

I will say that in the first 25 minutes of the third test the wee abs were dominating the collisions and I was saying where are the hard tackles driving them back. The wee abs were also tackling players beyond the ruck and coming in from the side. The ref picked up on the latter and in the second half eventual pinged them for the former.
There was a marked change in the second half with regard to offensive tackles.
I also note that even Marx in the first half didn't make any determined effort to go for the steal. Again that changed in the second half.

SA
Saffolk Captain30,894 posts
08 Sept 2026, 11:02
#3
08 Sept 2026, 11:02#3

Kolisi has been good in both the tests he has played - his return has us back to winning

Class player and brilliant leader

— END OF THREAD —

More from Rugby

More news